You wrote, ------------------------------------------------------------- Rand believed that children are born reasonable and that parenting and society make them less so. I don't think she observed many children. -------------------------------------------------------------
I never heard that about Rand, but if she actually thought that way she was wrong, and you're probably right. Someone who thinks like that probably hasn't been around a lot of children, especially young children.
I wouldn't say that child prodigies don't exist, but their rare and its unlikely someone would come up with a philosophy, an entire world view when they were only two years old.
Actually looking back at the quote it was more that children expect to deal with a rational universe. From Atlas Shrugged, p. 978
"In that morning you'll be able to rise in the morning with the spirit you knew in your childhood: that spirit of eagerness, adventure and certainty that comes from dealing with a rational universe. No child is afraid of nature;"
A slightly less silly claim than I had thought, but not much. Children believe in a more rational world than do adults? The monsters in my closet at age 8 beg do differ. I remember as a child the oppressiveness of so much of the world being beyond my understanding being a near constant feeling.
11 comments:
It's not a temper tantrum; the little girl is just a "passionate valuer."
I think I heard her scream, "A is A!"
And it's not "mommyyyy," it's "identity."
yup: scream for the camera, dear. you can look yourself up in the Wayback Machine. modern parenting skills.
Rand believed that children are born reasonable and that parenting and society make them less so. I don't think she observed many children.
Harq al-Ada,
You wrote,
-------------------------------------------------------------
Rand believed that children are born reasonable and that parenting and society make them less so. I don't think she observed many children.
-------------------------------------------------------------
I never heard that about Rand, but if she actually thought that way she was wrong, and you're probably right. Someone who thinks like that probably hasn't been around a lot of children, especially young children.
Here is some more reality.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxPmzIKBris
Anonymous,
I wouldn't say that child prodigies don't exist, but their rare and its unlikely someone would come up with a philosophy, an entire world view when they were only two years old.
Actually looking back at the quote it was more that children expect to deal with a rational universe. From Atlas Shrugged, p. 978
"In that morning you'll be able to rise in the morning with the spirit you knew in your childhood: that spirit of eagerness, adventure and certainty that comes from dealing with a rational universe. No child is afraid of nature;"
A slightly less silly claim than I had thought, but not much. Children believe in a more rational world than do adults? The monsters in my closet at age 8 beg do differ. I remember as a child the oppressiveness of so much of the world being beyond my understanding being a near constant feeling.
I think if an ill tempered toddler in the terrible twos could philosophize, the result would be pretty much what Rand came up with in middle age.
Post a Comment